RFE, NOID, I-290B, AAO
Get the file first: FOIA requests before an appeal or a lawsuit
- Statute
- 5 U.S.C. 552
- Initial determination
- 20 working days
- Where
- first.uscis.gov
Denial letters summarise. The record behind them is often fuller, sometimes different, and occasionally wrong. Before an employer commits to an appeal or a lawsuit, it helps to see what the officer saw, and the Freedom of Information Act is the ordinary way to get it.
Why the record matters
Both an administrative appeal and an APA claim are argued on the record that existed when USCIS decided. A missing exhibit, a misfiled response or an internal note can change the strategy: an error in the file points to reconsideration, while a gap the employer created points to a fresh filing. The review standard in court is described in challenging a denial under the APA.
How to request
USCIS's FOIA and Privacy Act page says requests should be made online through first.uscis.gov after creating an account. Under FOIA and the Privacy Act a requester can obtain their own records and someone else's records with that person's written permission. For an employer, that second point matters: the beneficiary's records are the beneficiary's, so the company or its counsel needs a signed consent, and the employee may also want their own counsel, as discussed in separate counsel for the employee.
- Name the specific receipt numbers and forms, and ask for the full adjudication record, including notes and any security-check results that may be released.
- Request the petitioner's file and, with consent, the beneficiary's file; they are not the same.
- Keep the request, the acknowledgement and every response in the evidence file.
What the statute requires of the agency
The Act requires an agency to determine within 20 days, excluding weekends and legal public holidays, whether it will comply with a request, as set out in 5 U.S.C. 552(a)(6)(A). In unusual circumstances the agency may extend that by written notice, normally by no more than ten working days. If the agency misses the statutory limits, the requester is deemed to have exhausted administrative remedies and can sue. Mandamus.com covers that route in when the government won't give you your records, and its case study on a FOIA request behind an I-485 denial shows how the record can reshape a case.
Do not let FOIA run the calendar
The FOIA clock and the appeal clock are not aligned. USCIS's Form I-290B page gives 30 days from service of a decision, or 33 if mailed, for most motions and appeals, and a FOIA response may take longer. The safe sequence is:
- File the FOIA request on the day of the denial.
- Prepare the motion or appeal on what the employer already has, and file it on time.
- Use the released record to decide whether to pursue the appeal, refile or go to court, as compared in the three routes after a denial.
Security-related holds are where records help most and are released least. Where a case was delayed by vetting, as described in security re-vetting in 2026, expect withholdings and use what is released to frame the next step rather than waiting for a complete file.
Questions
- How quickly must USCIS respond to a FOIA request?
- The statute requires a determination within 20 working days, extendable in unusual circumstances, normally by no more than ten working days.
- Can an employer request the employee's records?
- Only with the employee's written permission, according to USCIS's FOIA page.
- Should an appeal wait for the FOIA response?
- No. The motion or appeal deadline is generally 30 days, or 33 if the decision was mailed, and it does not pause for FOIA.
General information, not legal advice. Rules and processing practice change; verify against the agency's own published figures and take advice on your own facts.
On mandamus.com
Federal litigation practice pages covering this area: