RFE, NOID, I-290B, AAO
Denials, RFEs & Appeals
Delay is not the only way a case goes wrong. A request for evidence, a notice of intent to deny or a denial each starts a short, strict clock. This section covers the deadlines, the choice between a motion, an appeal and a fresh filing, and when a federal court can review the decision.
After a USCIS denial: how a business should select appeal and federal-court counsel
Counsel-selection checklist for an I-140, I-129 or other employment-petition denial: deadlines, appellate routes, the record and employee risk.
RFE or NOID: the response clock an employer actually has
USCIS can allow up to twelve weeks to answer a request for evidence and thirty days for a notice of intent to deny, and it cannot extend either. How to run that clock.
USCIS's "definition of day" change from 23 October 2026: which deadlines still roll to Monday
Policy Alert PA-2026-15 returns USCIS to its pre-2023 reading of "day". Periods stated in days still roll past a weekend; birthdays and other dates do not.
Form I-290B for employers: motion to reopen, motion to reconsider or appeal
A denied employment petition can be challenged on Form I-290B within 30 days, or 33 if the decision was mailed. Which route fits which denial, and the October 2026 address change.
After a denial: AAO appeal, a fresh filing or federal court
Three ways forward after an employment-based denial, compared on time, cost and what each can actually deliver, including when an administrative appeal is not required before suing.
When a mandamus case ends in a denial
Mandamus can force USCIS to decide; it cannot force an approval. What an employer should prepare before filing, and what the options are if the decision comes back negative.
Challenging an employment-based denial under the APA
When a petition is denied rather than delayed, the federal claim is APA review of a final decision. The standard, the record, the six-year limit and the jurisdictional traps.
Get the file first: FOIA requests before an appeal or a lawsuit
An appeal or APA claim is argued on the record USCIS actually had. How to obtain it through FOIA, what the statute requires of the agency, and how not to miss the 30-day window.