Mandamus, APA, TRAC
Why a company cannot file its own mandamus case
- Statute
- 28 U.S.C. 1654
- Leading case
- Rowland v. California Men's Colony (1993)
- Corporate plaintiff
- Counsel required
HR leaders who read about employees suing USCIS on their own sometimes ask whether the company can do the same and save the legal fees. It cannot. A corporation can be a plaintiff in a delay case, but in federal court it must act through a lawyer, and that rule shapes who files, who pays and who controls the case.
The rule
28 U.S.C. 1654 allows parties in federal courts to plead and conduct their own cases personally or by counsel, as the courts' rules permit. For individuals that permits self-representation. For companies it does not: in Rowland v. California Men's Colony the Supreme Court described the long-standing rule that artificial entities, such as corporations, may appear in federal court only through licensed counsel. An HR director, general manager or in-house non-lawyer cannot sign the complaint for the company.
Representation before USCIS and representation in court are also different questions. USCIS's page on finding legal services explains who may help with immigration filings, including attorneys and accredited representatives; a federal lawsuit is a separate matter governed by the court's own rules, and for a company that means a lawyer admitted to practise there.
The mandamus statute itself is no obstacle to a corporate plaintiff. 28 U.S.C. 1361 gives district courts jurisdiction over actions in the nature of mandamus to compel an officer or employee of the United States or any agency to perform a duty owed to the plaintiff. A petitioning employer is often the party to whom the duty is owed; the question is only who speaks for it.
The employee can file alone, but should they?
The beneficiary of a petition may file in their own name without a lawyer, and Mandamus.com's pro se guide explains how. For an employer that is a mixed outcome. The company is not a party, so it does not control the pleadings, the settlement discussions or the timing, and after the Supreme Court's 2025 ruling on universal injunctions relief may not reach a non-party, a point developed in after Trump v. CASA. A self-represented employee is also more exposed to the procedural defences described in venue for a corporate plaintiff.
Three workable structures
- The company as plaintiff, through counsel. The employer retains litigation counsel and files as petitioner, with or without the employee as co-plaintiff. This is the structure the business case usually assumes.
- Company and employee, each represented. Where interests could diverge, for example if the employee may leave or the role may change, separate counsel avoids conflicts. The issues are set out in separate counsel for the employee and on Mandamus.com's page on hiring a separate attorney.
- Existing immigration counsel with litigation co-counsel. Many business immigration firms do not litigate. A co-counsel arrangement keeps the immigration file with the firm that built it, as described in Mandamus.com's page on mandamus co-counsel.
What it costs
Counsel is a cost the self-represented employee does not pay, but it is rarely the decisive line. The delay itself, priced with the delay cost calculator against the agency's published processing times, usually dwarfs it. Some of the fees may be recoverable; the corporate limits are explained in EAJA for corporate plaintiffs.
Questions
- Can a company file a mandamus action without a lawyer?
- No. Corporations and other artificial entities may appear in federal court only through licensed counsel.
- Can the employee file without a lawyer?
- Yes, an individual may represent themselves, but the company is then not a party and does not control the case.
- Is the company a proper plaintiff in a delay case?
- Often yes. The mandamus statute covers duties owed to the plaintiff, and the petitioning employer is frequently the party the duty is owed to.
General information, not legal advice. Rules and processing practice change; verify against the agency's own published figures and take advice on your own facts.
On mandamus.com
Federal litigation practice pages covering this area: