Mandamus.biz The business cost of immigration delay

Payroll, hiring, operations

The cost of a denial versus the cost of delay

Decision window after denial
30 days (33 if mailed)
Deciding office review
Up to 45 days
Tool
Delay cost calculator

Published

Every delay case contains a quiet assumption: that a decision, once forced, will be favourable. On a strong file that assumption is safe. On a borderline one, a fast denial can cost more than a slow approval, and the comparison deserves the same arithmetic as the delay itself.

Two different cost shapes

Delay costs accumulate. Each month adds blocked productivity, extra filings and attrition risk, the components behind the cost-of-delay method. A denial costs in a step. It ends whatever status or work authorisation depended on the pending case, starts a short decision window and may force a choice between an appeal, a new filing and court.

That window is short. USCIS's Form I-290B page gives 30 days from service of most decisions, or 33 if mailed, and 15 or 18 days for appeals from immigrant-petition revocations. Under 8 CFR 103.3(a)(2) the deciding office then has 45 days to treat an appeal as a motion before forwarding it. The routes are compared in AAO appeal, refiling or federal court.

A worked comparison

The figures are assumptions for illustration, not data. Take a role with a fully burdened cost of $180,000 a year, a case already nine months past the published processing time, and two options: keep waiting, or file a delay suit expected to produce a decision within a few months.

  • Waiting. If a fifth of the role is blocked, each further month costs about $3,000 in productivity, before attrition risk.
  • Forcing a decision on a strong file. The cost is counsel's fee plus a few months of continued delay, against the end of an open-ended cost.
  • Forcing a decision on a weak file. Add the probability of a denial multiplied by its cost: a new filing, possibly a fresh PERM, months of lost time and, for an employee past six years, the risks described in a denial and the H-1B beyond six years.

On a weak file, a one-in-three chance of a denial costing $60,000 adds $20,000 of expected cost, enough to change the answer. The delay cost calculator handles the delay side; the denial side has to be estimated case by case.

Reducing the denial side

The cheapest way to shrink the denial cost is to strengthen the file before forcing a decision. That means reviewing the petition as an officer would after the RFE clock starts, updating facts that have changed and deciding in advance how a denial would be answered. The logic is developed in when a mandamus case ends in a denial.

Where fees fit

Litigation counsel's fees sit on the delay side of the comparison, and in some cases part of them can be recovered. The corporate eligibility limits are explained in EAJA for corporate plaintiffs, and Mandamus.com summarises how EAJA fee recovery works in mandamus litigation. Neither changes the core point: a decision is only worth forcing when the employer would be content to receive it.

Questions

Why compare the cost of a denial with the cost of delay?
Because forcing a decision on a weak file can produce a denial whose cost exceeds the delay it ended.
How long does an employer have to respond to a denial?
In most cases 30 days from service, or 33 if mailed, for a motion or appeal on Form I-290B.
Are the figures in the example real?
No. They are illustrative assumptions; replace them with the employer's own.

General information, not legal advice. Rules and processing practice change; verify against the agency's own published figures and take advice on your own facts.

On mandamus.com

Federal litigation practice pages covering this area: