Mandamus.biz The business cost of immigration delay

EB-1, EB-2, EB-3

An I-140 or PERM denial and the H-1B beyond six years: what the regulation protects

Delay route
8 CFR 214.2(h)(13)(iii)(D)
Per-country route
8 CFR 214.2(h)(13)(iii)(E)
During the appeal window
Denial not final

Published

For many sponsored employees the sixth H-1B year is not a deadline, because the green card process carries them past it. That bridge rests on a labour certification or immigrant petition, and a denial can knock it away. The regulation is precise about when, and the precision is worth money.

Two routes past six years

8 CFR 214.2(h)(13)(iii) provides two exemptions from the six-year limit. Under paragraph (D), the lengthy adjudication delay exemption, an employee is eligible if at least 365 days have passed since a labour certification or an immigrant visa petition was filed on their behalf. Approvals under that route may be granted in increments of up to one year. Under paragraph (E), the per-country limitation exemption, an employee who is the beneficiary of an approved EB-1, EB-2 or EB-3 petition and is eligible for the green card but for the per-country limit may stay beyond six years; the petitioner must show that a visa is unavailable as of the date the H-1B petition is filed.

The practical consequences for extensions blocked by a pending petition are covered in H-1B extensions and a pending I-140.

When a denial ends the protection

Under paragraph (D)(2), approvals under the delay route continue until the labour certification expires or a final decision is made to deny or revoke the labour certification, deny or revoke the immigrant petition, decide the immigrant visa or adjustment application, or administratively close any of them. Paragraph (D)(3) then adds the provision employers most often overlook: a decision to deny or revoke a labour certification or an immigrant petition is not considered final during the period authorised for filing an appeal, or while an appeal is pending.

In other words, the appeal window is part of the protection. For an I-140 the window is generally 30 days from service, or 33 if the decision was mailed, according to USCIS's Form I-290B page; the choices are set out in Form I-290B for employers. For a PERM denial, a request for review under 20 CFR 656.26 must be made within 30 days; see reconsideration or BALCA review. The regulation's text refers to appeals; whether a motion to reopen or reconsider has the same effect for this purpose should be confirmed with counsel before choosing a motion over an appeal.

Advance filing

The same paragraph allows a petitioner to file an H-1B petition seeking the delay exemption within six months of the requested start date, even before 365 days have passed, provided the labour certification or petition will have been on file for 365 days by the time the requested period begins. Paragraph (E) has a parallel advance-filing rule. Used well, these provisions let an employer file the extension early enough that an RFE, which now carries the risks described in the RFE and NOID response clock, does not collide with the end of the current period.

The day a denial arrives

  • Record the decision date and the method of service, and calculate the appeal deadline the same day.
  • Identify every H-1B extension that depends on the denied case, including any filed or planned under the advance-filing rules.
  • Decide quickly whether to appeal, refile or both; a fresh PERM or I-140 does not inherit the old filing date for the 365-day count. The three routes are compared in AAO appeal, refiling or federal court.
  • Tell the employee in writing what has happened and what the employer intends to do, so that their own planning is not built on assumptions.

Where the problem is a petition that will not be decided at all, the remedy is different: Mandamus.com explains the delay route for stalled I-140s.

Questions

Does an I-140 denial immediately end H-1B extensions beyond six years?
Not under the delay route. The regulation says the denial is not final during the period allowed for an appeal or while an appeal is pending.
Can an extension beyond six years be filed early?
Yes. The regulation allows filing within six months of the requested start date, subject to the 365-day condition being met by the time the period begins.
Does a motion have the same effect as an appeal?
The regulation refers to appeals. Confirm the position with counsel before relying on a motion.

General information, not legal advice. Rules and processing practice change; verify against the agency's own published figures and take advice on your own facts.

On mandamus.com

Federal litigation practice pages covering this area: