Mandamus.biz The business cost of immigration delay

Department of Labor

A denied PERM: reconsideration or BALCA review within 30 days

Reconsideration
30 days, 20 CFR 656.24(g)
Review
BALCA, 20 CFR 656.26
Missed deadline
Denial becomes final

Published

After a year or more in the Department of Labor queue, a PERM denial lands with a 30-day fuse. The employer can ask the same office to look again, ask the Board of Alien Labor Certification Appeals to review, or start over. The rules limit what each request may contain, and those limits usually decide the choice.

The two requests

Under 20 CFR 656.24(g), the employer may request reconsideration within 30 days of the date the denial was issued. For applications filed after 16 July 2007, the request may include only two kinds of documentation: material the Department actually received from the employer in response to a request from the certifying officer, or material the employer had no earlier opportunity to present but which existed when the application was filed and was kept to support it under the retention rules.

Under 20 CFR 656.26, a request for review by the Board must be sent within 30 days of the determination to the certifying officer who denied the application. It must identify the determination, set out the particular grounds, and include a copy of the final determination.

The cost of missing the window

The denial notice itself must warn that failing to request review within 30 days is a failure to exhaust administrative remedies and that the denial then becomes the final determination of the Secretary. For an employer, that means a missed deadline closes the administrative route and weakens any later court challenge. Calendar the 30 days from the date on the determination, not from when someone noticed the email.

Choosing between them

  • Reconsideration suits a denial that overlooked something already in the record or retained in the audit file. It is quicker to prepare and goes back to an office that can simply correct itself.
  • Board review suits a denial that turns on how a regulation should be read. The Board can settle a legal question, but submissions to it may contain only legal argument and evidence that was within the record on which the denial was based.
  • A new application suits a denial caused by a defect in recruitment or in the form itself. It repeats recruitment and the prevailing wage step, so its cost is mostly time, which the current FLAG queues make expensive.

The retention rule is why audit discipline matters so much. Documentation that existed when the application was filed and was properly kept can still be used on reconsideration; documentation created afterwards cannot. The habits described in responding to a PERM audit are what make reconsideration a real option.

Time and the sponsored employee

A PERM denial can affect H-1B extensions beyond the sixth year, which depend on a pending or approved labor certification or immigrant petition. Before deciding, check the employee's position under the AC21 extension rules and whether a new filing could be made in time to preserve it. Where the problem was delay rather than denial, the remedies are different and are covered in PERM delays at the Department of Labor and on Mandamus.com's page on PERM labor certification mandamus.

The general comparison between appealing, refiling and suing applies here too; see after a denial: the three routes, read with the Board substituted for the AAO.

Questions

How long does an employer have to challenge a PERM denial?
30 days, both for reconsideration under 20 CFR 656.24(g) and for a request for Board review under 20 CFR 656.26.
Can new documents be added on reconsideration?
Only documents DOL actually received in response to a request, or documents that existed at filing, were properly retained and could not be presented earlier.
What if the 30 days pass?
The denial becomes the final determination of the Secretary and the failure counts as a failure to exhaust administrative remedies.

General information, not legal advice. Rules and processing practice change; verify against the agency's own published figures and take advice on your own facts.

On mandamus.com

Federal litigation practice pages covering this area: